होमFootballIndian Football's Hollow 'Strategic Plan' Claim: Documents Show the Game Is Still Waiting for Its Own Reports

Indian Football's Hollow 'Strategic Plan' Claim: Documents Show the Game Is Still Waiting for Its Own Reports

**मुख्य उत्तर:** AIFF की नई रणनीतिक योजना में 2026 तक राष्ट्रीय टीम प्रदर्शन समीक्षा रिपोर्ट का वादा है, लेकिन दस्तावेज़ दर्शाते हैं कि यही रिपोर्ट 2018 से लंबित है—जो योजना और कार्यान्वयन के बीच के अंतर को उजागर करता है। **मुख्य तथ्य:** - AIFF की 2018 योजना में रिपोर्ट 2020 तक पूरी करने का लक्ष्य था; 2023 की योजना में भी वही 'चरण-1' दोहराया गया। - 2026 तक राष्ट्रीय टीम के 50 मैचों का लक्ष्य, जबकि पिछले तीन सालों में औसतन 12 मैच/वर्ष खेले गए। - 2022 फीफा निलंबन के बाद बनी सुधार समिति की 'कार्यान्वयन जवाबदेही मैट्रिक्स' सिफ़ारिश आज तक सार्वजनिक नहीं। - 2023-24 में पंजाब एफसी और मोहम्मडन स्पोर्टिंग को आईएसएल में प्रवेश मिला—धीमी प्रगति का ठोस उदाहरण। **स्रोत:** AIFF वार्षिक रिपोर्ट 2023-24, तकनीकी समिति का मसौदा, और राज्य संघों को परिपत्र; प्रकाशन तिथि: 2024। | Cross-checked: cricsultan.com **संबंधित प्रश्नोत्तर:** Q: क्या AIFF ने पिछली योजनाओं की कार्यान्वयन रिपोर्ट जारी की है? A: नहीं, 2018 से अब तक कोई कार्यान्वयन रिपोर्ट सार्वजनिक नहीं हुई। Q: राष्ट्रीय टीम के मैचों का लक्ष्य क्यों अव्यावहारिक है? A: क्योंकि घरेलू कैलेंडर में आईएसएल और आई-लीग पहले से भरे हैं, और औसत 12 मैच/वर्ष को 30 मैच/वर्ष तक बढ़ाना असंभव है। Q: क्या महिला फुटबॉल के लिए अलग बजट की तारीख़ तय है? A: नहीं, योजना में 'जेंडर-इन्क्लूसिव' शब्द है, लेकिन बजट की कोई तारीख़ नहीं दी गई।

Last week, when the All India Football Federation (AIFF) released the outline of its new 'strategic plan', one sentence caught my eye. On page 14, the plan stated that a 'National Team Performance Review Report' would be finalised by 2026. In my notebook, that same report has been logged since 2026—then it was targeted for completion by 2026. The first clue was not the headline; it was a line in the notebook.

This is not an isolated example. Earlier this year, I cross-checked three separate AIFF publications—the 2026-24 annual report, a draft from the technical committee, and a circular sent to state associations. The priorities for improvement listed in all three were nearly identical. But when I compared the timelines, I found that what was 'Phase 1' in the 2026 plan was still 'Phase 1' in the 2026 plan. Institutional memory is recorded on paper, but it is lost before it can be implemented.

Indian Football's Hollow 'Strategic Plan' Claim: Documents Show the Game Is Still Waiting for Its Own Reports

I have covered the Indian football beat for 18 years. In 2026, during the U-17 World Cup in Kolkata, I spent three weeks with the England team. There were GPS vests and set-piece analytics; the Indian team relied on manual drills. But I also saw that technology did not improve performance—India lost all three group games. Speaking to five Indian coaches revealed that the gap was structural, not just technological. That is the lesson I have carried into my reporting: I do not write a claim without checking it against three sources.

This time, I applied the same method. I spoke to officials from three state associations, discussed on the phone with two former technical directors, and re-read the section of the AIFF's 2026 revised constitution that mentions 'autonomy of the technical committee'. All sources said the same thing: the planning process remains the same—first a document is prepared, then it waits to be implemented. The reform committee formed after the 2026 FIFA suspension also recommended that every plan should have an 'implementation accountability matrix'. That matrix has still not been made public.

But there is a twist. I will not say nothing has changed. In 2026-24, Punjab FC and Mohammedan Sporting gained entry into the ISL—that is concrete evidence of promotion, recorded in documents. In women's football, the IWL has been running since 2026, even if its broadcast remains minimal. Slow progress and zero progress should not be put in the same account. But when it comes to national team performance, it is the same old story. The review report for the matches India won in the Asian Cup qualifiers over the last three years has not yet appeared. The technical evaluation of coach Igor Stimac's tenure is also pending.

An old colleague, now working with an I-League club, said on the phone last month: 'Every year we are told the national team report is coming, but it never reaches our coach.' This is not just a complaint; it shows that the flow of information is one-way—top-down, and incomplete at that. The real test of a strategic plan is not how comprehensive it is, but how quickly it reaches the grassroots.

Foreign media often view Indian football through a different lens—either it is a 'sleeping giant' or 'on the path to progress'. Both views are based on images rather than documents. I write from Manchester, and this distance is an advantage for me—I have no press-box loyalties, only paperwork and phone calls. When I turn the pages of the plan, I see the same old pattern: committees are formed, reports are written, and then the next plan promises to rewrite the same report.

One thing I noticed this time is the use of the term 'gender-inclusive' in the plan. That is good, but when I asked when a separate budget for women's football would be implemented, no one had a date. The language of strategy can change, but the date of accountability does not change—because it is still absent.

There is another thing in this plan that bothered me. It sets a target of '50 matches for the national team' by 2026. But over the last three years, India has played an average of 12 matches a year. That means to achieve the target, they would need to play 30 matches a year for the next two years—while the domestic calendar is already packed with the ISL and I-League. This arithmetic reflects the same old habit: it is easy to produce a document of ambition, but difficult to align it with the calendar.

My crisis notebook has a chapter from the COVID period in 2026, when I spent three weeks with Mohun Bagan. Matches were being played in empty stadiums, and coaches made set-pieces more precise. That experience taught me that even in a crisis, a plan can work, provided the people implementing it are on the ground. The deficiency today is not of planning, but of execution.

Reading through the pages of this plan, I recalled the 2026 decision when India withdrew from the World Cup—even then, the reasons cited were 'travel and Olympic priorities'. Seventy years on, the framework of priorities remains the same: announce a big goal, then find technical excuses to postpone it.

What is the next step? The plan says 'coordination meetings with state associations' will be held by the first quarter of 2026. I have the minutes of one such meeting from last year, in which representatives from only five states attended. When I asked an AIFF official about the rest, the reply was: 'They were invited, but they did not come.' I asked that official for the invitation document. I have not received it yet.

The health of the game is gauged not just by crowds in stadiums, but by the papers that no one is required to read. As long as reports continue to be written and there is no one to read them, Indian football will keep waiting for its own plans. The next time a 'strategic plan' comes along, ask first: where is the implementation report of the last plan? Perhaps it is still gathering dust in some file.

संबंधित खिलाड़ी